The ear has always been challenged by unfamiliar sounds. Play someone who is not well-trained in music a piece by Schoenberg, Berg or Webern, and they will probably describe it as “modern-sounding”, or something similar. Yet much of the music by these three classical composers who championed the ‘twelve-note’, ‘serialist’ or ‘atonal’ style of music was written over one hundred years ago. Although these atonal composers’ music is ripped-off in a vast number of movie soundtracks and film-scores, their music never made it into the mainstream as music in its own right, and possibly with good reason: it’s challenging to listen to because there’s no respite from the dissonance. But you can get used to it.
The other day, a boy walked on stage at a school rock concert with a bundle of wires and a guitar pieced together from the broken remains of other instruments. He sat down cross-legged in the middle of the stage; what followed was an array of noises the vast majority of the (captive) audience would never have sat through were it not for the context of an eclectic mix of bands performing one after the other, which seemed to be conducive towards an open-minded attitude from the crowd. Fuzz, distortion, static, rapid strumming on extremely dissonant chords (played on an instrument patently not even close to being ‘in tune’), and dive-bombing sounds reminiscent of the end of Jimi Hendrix’s famous Band of Gypsys recording of Machine Gun; this was something no one was expecting and which only a small collective of dedicated noise-rock fans in the audience would have ever heard before. Needless to say, there was a tumult of partially sarcastic applause after he had finished, far louder than was afforded any of the other acts that night.
Should people have to step outside their comfort zone and experience something different? In an ideal world, prejudice could be left at the door at this sort of event. Playing it safe and sticking to what you know where some things are concerned is generally considered to be acceptable, and music seems very often to be one such example. My hypothesis is this: taste in music isn’t as simple as taste in something like food where you may never learn to like something (marmite and liquorice being two obvious examples). Not only do people often say things like a song is ‘growing’ on them, suggesting people cannot really be absolutist in defining their taste by genres or even individual artists, but their tastes may change completely in the course of a few years.
‘Noise-rock’ is perhaps the best description for what that boy in the school rock concert was making, although in its absence of easily discernable harmony, melody or rhythm, it bore far less resemblance to ordinary rock music than most artists who are labelled as such. But maybe the underlying point is the same: it challenges one’s preconceptions about what is listenable, what aspects of music one enjoys, and becomes more of a sensory experience than a simple listening exercise. Being a ‘noise-rock fan’ must surely demand an ability to embrace the ugly, to leave aside musical prejudice and to reconsider your definition of music. John Cage’s credence that any sound can be music if afforded enough attention (culminating in the infamous 4’33”, which consists of 4 minutes and 33 seconds of silence) has had a lasting influence, and one need not look as far as noise-rock to see it: I can think of numerous pop records where there is a soundscape of noise, produced electronically or otherwise, which, while not integral to the song, provides texture and atmosphere and must surely be considered as part of the ‘music’.
The fact that a large roomful of people were exposed to a rather extreme example of noise-rock is, for me, highly commendable. Narrow-mindedness is endemic in music to an extent unparalleled in the other arts. It may require a certain degree of understanding, technical or otherwise, of some styles of music in order to fully appreciate them, but not enough people take the first step and actually listen to something just a little different. Why not start today?